why was palestine taken off the map

The Roman Empire actually expelled most of the Jews after 100 AD when they rebelled. We need to acknowledge it: the two-state solution is dead. But Palestine does not find an official marker on Google. This most likely has to do with the fact the United States does not officially recognize Palestine as a nation. It is not the first time when Google has done it, back in 2016 and 2018, it had been removed by Google from their maps but after protests back in 2016 and 2018, they had to bring it back. We're working quickly to bring these labels back to the area," a spokesperson says. USA TODAY reached out to the user for comment, to which they said "America doesnt recognize (Palestine)as a nation. DID APPLE AND GOOGLE REALLY REMOVE PALESTINE FROM MAPS? The history of Palestine is the study of the past in the region of Palestine, also known as the Land of Israel and the Holy Land, defined as the territory between the Mediterranean Sea and the Jordan River (where Israel and Palestine are today). Condemnation leads to outrage about Google removing country from map but the country has never been labelled on the mapping service. But we will always resist and prove our presence #PalestineIsHere pic.twitter.com/ISHYVYGxCj, I am changing my homepage and search engine. Israel has long contested the status of the Gaza Strip and West Bank, both recognised as Palestinian territories. They have since restored her original post. The Palestinians in Bethlehem and the Palestinian Israelis in Haifa are both living under the same apartheid Israeli regimebut they're experiencing it differently. Though Google never used (and therefore never removed) the "Palestine" label, many social media users and mainstream news sites believed that it did. In 2016, #PalestineIsHere began trending after supporters of the Palestinian cause condemned Google for supposedly removing the word "Palestine" from Google Maps, according to the New York Times.. Google changes Palestinian location from 'Territories' to 'Palestine', Palestinians win de facto U.N. recognition of sovereign state, Palestinian cities are ghost towns between settlements, on Google Maps, Social Media Users Slam Google, Apple for Deleting Palestine From Their Maps, You cansubscribe to our print edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here, Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. As of 2020 Palestine is a small piece of land which is roughly 2,400 square miles in size. ccording to Google, Palestine doesnt even exist. In countries where we have local versions of Google Maps, we follow local legislation when displaying names and borders. Located to the north of Jerusalem, in the central part of the West Bank is the city of Ramallah - the current administrative center of Palestine. Other major mapping companies approach this decision in different ways. By entering your email and clicking Sign Up, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. The conflict between Israel and Palestine is such a contentious topic that the very name of the respective nations has sparked debate. Palestine holds great importance in Muslim world. The Canary Workers Co-op knows life is hard. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Staff Desk of The Islamic Information covers the latest news and valuable information that Muslim readers need. Its Palestinian landall of it. Thats not something that we tend to think about often, but it does become pretty obvious when a map changes/is said to have changed, or when we compare different maps against each other. Thank you for supporting our journalism. So, I genuinely dont understand how you can say that Israelis are superior to Arabs, or that British South Africa is a thing. We discovered a bug that removed the labels for West Bank and Gaza Strip, the Google spokesperson said. For example: users in Russia see a solid boundary line around Russia and Crimea. Israeli Settlements | IMEU Policy Backgrounder, The Nakba and Palestine Refugees | IMEU Questions and Answers, The Gaza Strip | IMEU Policy Backgrounder, Fact Sheet: Meet Israels New Government (December 2022). There has never been a Palestine label on Google Maps, said a spokesperson. PUT PALESTINE BACK ON THE MAP. A thin, grey line marks boundaries of a disputed, occupied region - but nowhere does the country have a name. Funny how many "activists" never had the curiosity to look at it on the premier interactive map of the modern world, just shows how much of it is just ignorant social signaling. #PalestineIsHere pic.twitter.com/uQfIDcJOka, Shame on you @google ! The global tracker for cases from Johns Hopkins University no longer lists Palestine. Copyright Network18 Media and Investments Ltd 2020. It's restoring the labels "West Bank" and "Gaza" after accidentally deleting them. Google has always attempted to stay out of regions where there are border disputes, including Kashmir in India and Pakistan. 61. An apartheid regime. The representation of Palestine on Google Maps has not changed recently, but after the forum of Palestinian journalists released a statement condemning Google, word spread via social media and later news outlets. "Were working quickly to bring these labels back to the area., DON'T MISSTrumps scandalous peace plan legitimises colonisation- VIDEOTrump peace plan: Why a two-state solution WONT work- ANALYSISPrince Charles: How heir to throne stunned in 'dangerous' Iran visit- INSIGHT. 71 Windsor St, Salisbury, SP2 7EA, UK, Google Removes Palestine From Google Maps, 5 Lessons To Learn From Surah Yusuf That Will Make Your Life Better, Eid Ul Adha 2020 Salah To Be Offered In Masjid al-Haram and Nabawi, Saudi Arabia Lowers Umrah Cost in 2023 For Foreign Pilgrims, India Demolished Historical Mosque in UP To Widen The Road, Over 2 Million Pilgrims To Perform The Hajj 2023, Iranian Imam Meets with Netanyahu Officials in Secret Visit to Israel, 12 Facts Every Muslim Need To Know About Abu Bakr (RA), Women Can Perform Hajj and Umrah Without Mahram, Quran And Islamic Books Torned In Attack On Jamia Abdullah Bin Masood Mosque in Sheffield, Worlds First 3D Mosque To Be Built In Dubai By 2025, Jeddah Airport Now Provides Free Shuttle Service To Masjid al-Haram For Umrah and Hajj Pilgrims, Answers To Frequently Asked Questions About Islam, Muslim Teen Stabbed To Death On Way Home From Mosque in Dublin, Hindutva mobs vandalize mosques and Muslim homes in India in response to last weeks attack, Omar Suleiman Arrested Among Others In Washington DC, From Muhammad SAWW to Adam AS An Overview. The city of Jerusalem is marked, and it appears almost like Google has classified Palestine as a part of Israel - with no identity of its own. They would starve to death anyway, mind as well die honorably while resisting rather than die silently. Apple and Google have been accused of deleting Palestine from their online maps, despite it never being labelled in the first place. You cannot Undo it by removing it from the World Map.Disappeared Palestine from the world map is a serious crime. Users can only see Israel in it and Jerusalem, which Israel has claimed that it belongs to them after forcing the worshippers out of the Al-Aqsa Mosque. Printed 1/18/23 - 3:18:09 After years of occupation, Gazas broken hospitals simply cant cope: 56 ventilators. One Twitter user posted: "Google and Apple have removed #Palestine from their maps, something the Israeli occupation has been wishing since long time! In 2016 too, Google Maps was accused of deleting Palestine off the Maps. Back then, attention was brought to the issue after the forum of Palestinian journalists released a statement condemning Google. Our fact check work is supported in part by a grant from Facebook. The map also shows Israel existing in 1946. The issue has sparked concern primarily from supporters of Palestine, which is yet to receive full global recognition. Palestine was never ON google maps to begin with. But there is no mention of Palestine. This, to me, is bullying. Searched why Palestine was trending. The following is a fact check of MSNBCs map and the criticisms of it. Back in 2016, Google had clarified that they had never included Palestine as a searchable option in their Maps application. I dont actually remember if it was on there or not, because I dont use Google Maps or not, but maybe with this we can actually get it on there!!! "The original target was 1 million signatures, which was reached in July 2020," said Zak Martin, who created the petition. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. Palestine doesnt appear as a separate country on Google Maps either. Yes. Why not? Apple Maps, similar to Google, zooms in on the region but doesn't label anything as Palestine. The map purported to show Palestinian Loss of Land 1946-present, and it did precisely that, accurately. Sign up and we will email you daily with the best of our political and news coverage while also giving you a taste of our most-popular lifestyle, opinion and personal blogs. Even the smallest donation would mean the world to us. Fact Check:Netanyahu did not give a speech thanking Hamas for uniting Israel. Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. Viral video doesn't show Hamas staging child's funeral, Netanyahu did not give a speech thanking Hamas for uniting Israel, No, Google Says, It Did Not Delete Palestine From Its Maps, Google Maps did not delete Palestine but it does impact how you see it, Map: The countries that recognize Palestine as a state. While 136 members of the United Nations recognise Palestine as an independent state, the US and much of the west does not. And more and more Muslims are joining the social media protests. Jul. Anyone searching Palestine on Google Maps right now would be brought to a geographical boundary labelled only as Israel. 2023 USA TODAY, a division of Gannett Satellite Information Network, LLC. I am Algerian, and I know full well we dont refer to it as French Algeria. In fact; the Algerian kicked out the French colonisers after a bloody war of indpendance, which we now celebrate every 5th July. According to Palestinian Chronicle, it initially listed Palestine and Israel separately. The petition reads: The country of Palestine does not appear on Google maps. There is no label reading Palestine, but that has always been the case. Israel seized Palestinian land, commits countless atrocities, is in breach of international law and operates an evil apartheid system. The decision ignited a long-lasting conflict which continues to this day, with advocates for. Trump's genocidal policies are planting the seeds of violence, and will reap more violence. Dear @googlemaps, Palestine exists! Zionism meaning: What is Zionism, what does it mean. Last week, MSNBC aired a map (above) showing loss of Palestinian land to Zionist settlers and then to Israel from 1946 to the present. Google said that as part of itsefforts to provide a more comprehensive map, it publishedStreet View imagery of the West Bank in 2017, specificallyRamallah, Bethlehem and Jericho. A Gaza City journalism group spotted a change in the way Google represented Palestine on a map of Israel, causing outrage on both mainstream and social media in the Middle East. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Under Turkish rule, "Palestine" was part of southern Syria, not independent. A petition from March this year urging Google to include Palestine on their maps has gained traction in the last few days, now with almost 250,000 signatures. Offers may be subject to change without notice. Lots of Muslims took to Social Media to protest against this move. Sorry, we are unable to accept comments about this article at the moment. Today Google and Apple Maps have officially taken Palestine off the world map, further pushing the agenda of erasing Palestine from the world, WE CAN NOT SIT BY AND LET A COUNTRY BE ERASED FROM HISTORY IN THIS DAY AND AGE! The hashtag #FreePalestine began trending on social media again after several tweets about the nation's omission from mapping services gained traction online. pic.twitter.com/i4zLjp48hv, Chris Williamson #GTTO (@DerbyChrisW) March 30, 2020, Let's all stand in solidarity with Palestine on the 44th anniversary of Palestine Land Day. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. According to Google, Palestine does not exist.. People began sharing their outrage using the hashtag #PalestineIsHere. But its since removed Palestine. A journalism group in Gaza claimed the region has been removed from Google Maps, calling it an attempt to falsify history and a crime against the areas 4.5 million residents. All rights reserved. However, a deeper look into the issue proves that it's a bit more complex than most people understand. Company registration number 14315286 Contact: [emailprotected]. Apple and Google are both American countries despite their worldwide reach, so it would make sense that they would base their mapping applications on America's officially recognized global, geographical borders and nomenclature. A report from Al Jazeera noted that many Palestinian people also fear that: At a time when the world is focused solely on the pandemic and the Israeli regime has the full support of the US administration to do as it pleases, Israeli aggressive expansionism seems inevitable. Outside of Russia, Crimea is surrounded by dashed lines, indicating it as occupied territory. Palestinian homes are bulldozed, children are arrested in the middle of the night, and acts of peaceful resistance are met with snipers and bombs. (JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address), What Congress Needs to Know about Palestine/Israel, Yes. Services like Google Maps have not just functional but symbolic importance, as a bug on a map of Israel has proved. Muslim leaders all around the world have been working to free Palestine and give them their right which they have been diprived of. Campaigners tweeted hashtags like #PalestineIsHere and #BoycottGoogle, and some said they would switch to Microsofts Bing maps service that labels Palestine as a discrete place. The Canary, PO Box 71196, London, SE20 9ET When Israel was established, a fresh-faced United Nations sought to divide land between the two states. Over 250,000 people have signed the petition. Google did, however, find a glitch that led to something being removed from the map, and could explain the concerns of the journalists in Gaza. But Googledid not do that, because the label was never there. A spokeswoman said: There has never been a Palestine label on Google Maps, however we discovered a bug that removed the labels for West Bank and Gaza Strip. Palestine is located in the Middle East, It is bordered by the countries of Syria, Lebanon, Jordan Egypt and Israel. Social media users have accused both Apple and Google of erasing Palestine, a partially recognised state and neighbour of Israel. Now, many public figures and users across multiple platforms are questioning Google and Apple's decisions to "remove" Palestine from their services. When searching for "Palestine" on Google Maps, the map zooms in on the Israel-Palestine region, andboth the Gaza Strip and West Bank territories are labeled andseparated bydottedlines. But its actually a strength, because it helps people understand the reality right nowthat Israel controls everything, and that under Israel, Jews are superior to Arabs. But was it? In the latest shocking update, Google has removed Palestine from Google Maps. Wait what? 138 United Nations members do, however, America is not one of them. However, there is no label recognising the state, which has triggered online protests. This is not the first time Google has got into hot water over disputed territories and its likely not to be the last. Let us know in the comment box below. She had accused IG of "bullying" her: "Instagram removed my story that only said 'My baba And his birthplace of Palestine' with a photograph of his American passport. The Palestinian people deserve our solidarity.It's time to stand up to Israel's apologists and back #BDS now. has pointed out that Googles rival Apple Maps service neither labels Palestine, or differentiates it at all from Israel. 2913 El Camino Real #436 Tustin, CA 92782, Institute for Middle East Understanding. im so angry i have no words". 2023 BuzzFeed, Inc. All rights reserved. Today Palestine was erased from the maps tomorrow Palestine will be erased from the world. ", Read all the Latest News, Breaking News and Coronavirus News here. Because 30 March is Land Day in Palestine. Just to make sense of your comment Second of all, are you seriously suggesting that Palestine submits to colonialism? #IStandWithPalestine #FreePalestine pic.twitter.com/zMn7EAbvBD ubs (@_graveyardd) July 16, 2020. Critics have focused on the fact that Palestine was not a sovereign and independent state prior to 1948, however the map did not claim that it was. Company registration number 09788095. Palestine, where part of the holy city of Jerusalem is located, has been rife with its border disputes: it has had annexation, it has had military occupations, it has had its territories being encroached, intifadas, and . A Wikipedia knowledge box on Maps describes Palestine as a "de jure sovereign state," a term selected by the United Nations in 2013. The state is marked out on the map, intersected with lines outlining Palestinian territory. With much of the world now in lockdown, for most Palestinian people this experience is nothing new. A controversy over the country, Palestine, erupted late on Thursday night, when Twitter users noticed that the country was missing from Google Maps. The claim that Palestine is not labeled on Google Maps is TRUE, based on our research. The photo was taken from Google maps which is a Leftist company. You cannot Undo it by removing it from the World Map.Disappeared Palestine from the world map is a serious crime.#WeRejectWorldMap pic.twitter.com/AOuyn2GBGn Uman Malik (@U_3322) July 17, 2020, Im really buggin out!! People taking a look at either map from the tech giants yielded a marking only for Israel, reigniting decades of debate. Canary Workers Co-op 2022. But in 2020, This moves looks like a solid one. Because of this, whenever any map of the region is drawn is becomes a political issue. I'm seeing it all over social media. An onlinepetitionasking Google to add a label for Palestine has accumulated more than 2.1 million signatures on Change.org. The Johns Hopkins Coronavirus Resource Center developed a vital tool to track the pandemic. Disrespectful. (sic)" The claim was also viral on Facebook. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Typing Palestine on Google maps will also point you to an approximate location - but no markers. That sparked a #PalestineIsHere hashtag, with many folks declaring that they'd deleted Google's services. ", Another user wrote: "google maps deleted palestine from its maps?? In 1948 Israel occupied part of Jerusalem and Palestine, whilst in 1967 Israel . The Canary doesnt have the budget of the corporate media. while it's unquestionably horrible that Palestine is not on the map, the disgusting truth is that Palestine was never actually on Google maps apparently. The truth is that from the river to the sea theres only one state right now. The global tracker for cases from Johns Hopkins University no longer lists Palestine. On 23 March, BTselem warned: The spread of COVID-19 in the Gaza Strip will be a massive disaster, resulting entirely from the unique conditions created by more than a decade of Israeli blockade: a failing healthcare system, extreme poverty, dependence on humanitarian aid, dysfunctional infrastructure and harsh living conditions that compromise public health even before exposure to the new virus combine with overcrowding to form a nightmare scenario. 40 ICU beds.For 2 million people living under a military blockade.#COVID19 will lead to unimaginable suffering for Palestinians in Gaza, #EndTheGazaBlockade NOW#PalestineLandDay pic.twitter.com/ZvwfAWKY20, VPalestine (@VPalestineT) March 28, 2020. Palestinians become more determined to resist and demand their rights as we see in Gaza. Putting Palestine on the maps further feeds into the idea that there are two states, or that Israel doesnt have full control over the land. Many people, after learning that Google and Apple hadn't "removed" Palestine from their Maps, wanted to know why it was never on there in the first place. So, according to Google, Palestine doesnt even exist. Searching for Palestine on the service brings up a dashed line around an unlabeled region, while Israel is clearly marked: An adjacent information box names Palestine and calls it a de jure sovereign state, following the current description from the UN. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. When doing a general search for "Palestine," here's what happens: Palestine is recognized as an independent state by the United Nations and more than 135 of its members, but it is not recognizedby theU.S.,according to History. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. In fact, our income is over. Recently, high-profile celebrities like Chris Evans and Bella Hadid have had their names brought up in discussions around Palestine, too. However, the Maps app never had that label in the first place, and Google tells Engadget that a glitch is to blame for the change. Israel/Palestine is in brown and white, found south of Lebanon and to the west of Jordan. More info. "There has never been a 'Palestine' label on Google Maps, however we discovered a bug that removed the labels for 'West Bank' and 'Gaza Strip.' Because it came with the latest update of Google Maps, which shows no sign of Palestine on the map. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Palestinians protest against US President Donald Trump's so-called Middle East peace plan on 1 February 2020 [Mostafa Alkharouf/Anadolu Agency] He cares not that Israel's expansion will, at a. So please, help us continue to spread messages of resistance and hope. Now, that decision is drawing renewed focus amid the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. By 27 March, there were nine confirmed cases in Gaza. Palestinians inPalestine live under a brutal military occupation that is largely funded by the 3.8 billion dollars that the US gives Israel yearly, more money than we give to any other country in the world. The area around Palestine has been shrouded in controversy since the 1900s. Amid the coronavirus (Covid-19) pandemic, Palestine has been removed from the map. But in the midst of our personal chaos and confusion, the challenges we face seem easy in comparison to those facing people in Palestine. This couldnt come at a more poignant time. https://imeu.org/article/fact-check-msnbcs-palestinian-loss-of-land-map/ Inhumane. But its not actually the case that Palestine has been deleted from Google Maps. pic.twitter.com/eE3IaF9Ffp Muhammad Smiry (@MuhammadSmiry) July 17, 2020, Palestine is reality. See our, As deaths occur and coronavirus cases start to rise in British prisons, campaigners express their concerns, What not to believe: coronavirus myths you should ignore.